A Rare Private Island Opportunity Off the Coast of Maine
For those who have always dreamed of owning their own piece of the world — completely removed from the noise, the crowds, and the ordinary — a truly extraordinary opportunity has just arrived. A 25-acre private island off the rugged coast of Georgetown, Maine, has hit the market, listed at $3.85 million. Known as Long Island, this rare offering delivers everything a discerning buyer could want: sweeping ocean vistas, deep historical roots, and the kind of absolute privacy that is nearly impossible to find anywhere else in New England.
Private island listings are genuinely rare. The combination of size, livable infrastructure, historical significance, and natural beauty makes this particular listing even more exceptional. Whether you are a luxury real estate investor, a history enthusiast, or simply someone searching for the ultimate personal retreat, Long Island deserves your full attention.
Where Is Long Island Located?
Long Island sits just off the shores of Georgetown, Maine — a small coastal town situated on a peninsula in Sagadahoc County. Georgetown is renowned among those who know the Maine coast well, offering a quieter, more unspoiled version of the classic New England seaside experience compared to more trafficked destinations like Bar Harbor or Kennebunkport.
The island's location gives it an almost mythical sense of seclusion. Surrounded by the cold, clear waters of the Gulf of Maine, the property provides a natural barrier from the outside world while still remaining accessible. The listing notes that the property includes mainland parking and access, meaning reaching the island — while private — is entirely practical for everyday use.
The Historic 1862 Waterfront Estate
At the heart of the property stands a stunning 3,346-square-foot Federal-style home built in 1862. This is not a modern construction dressed up in historical costume — it is a genuine piece of American architectural history, more than 160 years old and meticulously maintained. The home features four to five bedrooms and panoramic ocean views that stretch out across the Atlantic horizon.
The residence is surrounded by mature trees and rolling lawns, giving the estate a sense of grandeur that feels both timeless and deeply rooted in place. Federal-style architecture, which was popular throughout the northeastern United States in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, is characterized by its symmetry, refined detailing, and dignified proportions — qualities that remain highly desirable among historic home buyers today.
Legacy of Artist Stephen Etnier
One of the most compelling aspects of Long Island's history is its connection to Stephen Etnier, a renowned American artist celebrated for his luminous paintings of the Maine coast and Caribbean waters. Etnier, who lived from 1903 to 1984, was closely associated with the realist tradition and was known for capturing the particular quality of light over water in ways that earned him a devoted following among collectors and institutions alike.
The island served as Etnier's home and creative sanctuary, and his presence is still felt throughout the property. The listing highlights a large separate artist's studio that remains on the grounds — a dedicated creative space that adds both practical value and a profound sense of artistic legacy to the offering. For a buyer with an appreciation for American art history, the chance to own the former home and working studio of such a significant figure is genuinely priceless.
What Is Included in the $3.85 Million Listing?
The scope of what comes with this property is remarkable. Beyond the historic main residence and the artist's studio, the listing includes a comprehensive collection of structures and natural features that together create a fully self-contained private world.
- A substantial deep-water pier constructed from Deer Isle granite, offering direct boating access from the island itself.
- A traditional boathouse, ideal for storing watercraft and equipment year-round.
- Old stonework and perennial gardens that have been thoughtfully maintained across generations.
- An ancient orchard, adding a pastoral, living-history quality to the landscape.
- Waterfront meadows that roll down to meet the sea, providing open green space with unobstructed water views.
- Woodland walking trails that wind through the full 25 acres, offering private hiking and nature exploration.
- Mainland parking and access, ensuring the island is practical as a primary or secondary residence.
Critically, the listing notes that the entire property is protected under thoughtful conservation, meaning the island's natural character and ecological integrity are preserved well into the future. This conservation status not only protects the landscape but also adds long-term value by ensuring the surrounding environment will never be developed or altered.
Activities and Lifestyle on the Island
Life on Long Island means having a 25-acre natural playground entirely to yourself. The surrounding waters and rugged coastline of Midcoast Maine are world-class destinations for boating, kayaking, fishing, and sailing. The island's deep-water pier makes it straightforward to launch or dock a variety of vessels, from small kayaks to larger motorboats and sailboats.
On land, the woodland trails offer peaceful walks through old-growth forest, while the meadows and gardens provide space for relaxation, outdoor entertaining, and quiet reflection. The ancient orchard and perennial gardens bring seasonal color and the simple pleasure of tending to a living landscape that has been cultivated for well over a century.
About the Listing Agent
Long Island is listed by Poe Cilley of Vitalius Real Estate Group, a firm with deep expertise in the Maine luxury and coastal real estate market. Buyers interested in learning more about the property or scheduling a private showing are encouraged to reach out directly through the listing.
Is This the Ultimate Maine Escape?
There are vacation homes, and then there are properties that redefine what it means to get away. Long Island off Georgetown, Maine, belongs firmly in the second category. With its rare combination of historic architecture, artistic legacy, natural beauty, conservation protection, and absolute privacy, this 25-acre island is not merely a piece of real estate — it is an entire world unto itself, available for $3.85 million to the buyer who recognizes just how truly rare that is.
If you have ever imagined owning your own island, this may be the most compelling version of that dream you will ever encounter on the open market.